Metal vs. Plastic Shed: Which One Is the Right Choice for Your Backyard?

Choosing a storage shed might seem straightforward, but when you realize the material impacts everything from durability to maintenance, it can get complicated. Metal and plastic (resin) sheds are the two most popular choices in Canada, offering different strengths depending on your needs. This guide breaks down key factors like weather resistance, security, and maintenance, so you can make an informed decision that works for your backyard, budget, and lifestyle.

1. What Are They Actually Made Of?

Choosing a storage shed might seem simple, but it’s about more than just size material matters. If you’ve been considering a metal vs wood shed comparison, it’s worth noting that while metal and plastic (resin) sheds offer modern solutions, traditional wood sheds may still appeal to some for their classic look. 

Metal Sheds

• Made from galvanized steel, color-coated steel, or aluminum.
• Galvanized steel is the most durable, offering resistance to rust and corrosion, even in wet climates.
• Metal sheds are rigid, heavy, and interlocking, making them incredibly strong.

Plastic/Resin Sheds

• Constructed from high-density polyethylene (HDPE) or polypropylene (PP), designed to withstand UV exposure, moisture, and temperature changes without cracking or warping.
• Premium resin sheds, like those from Outsunny, feature double-wall construction and steel-reinforced frames for added strength, but still remain lightweight.

Key Insight: Metal sheds excel in raw strength, while resin sheds are corrosion-resistant and versatile, especially in moisture-heavy areas.

2. Durability & Weather Performance

Both shed materials are built to last, but their performance depends on how they handle different weather conditions and long-term use.

Metal Sheds

• Can last 20–30 years with proper maintenance.
• Galvanized steel resists impact and supports heavy loads like snow.
• Performs well in high winds and is fire-resistant.
• Prone to rust over time, but can be managed with protective coatings.
• May develop condensation inside, which can be reduced with ventilation.

Plastic/Resin Sheds

• Typically last 15–20 years under normal conditions.
• Naturally rust-proof, moisture-resistant, and insect-resistant.
• Ideal for rainy or humid climates.
• Lightweight models may shift in strong winds.
• Lower-quality resin can crack in extreme temperatures, while premium options include reinforced frames.

Key Insight: Metal sheds are ideal for heavy snow, strong winds, and fire resistance, while resin sheds are better for moisture-rich environments with minimal maintenance needs.

3. Security

If you’re storing expensive tools and equipment, security is key.

Metal Sheds

• High-security with steel panels that are hard to breach.
• Often come with lockable doors and reinforced frames, providing a solid security barrier against theft.

Plastic/Resin Sheds

• While plastic sheds can come with lockable doors, their walls can be compromised if enough force is applied.
• Resin sheds are best for storing garden tools or seasonal décor, but not for high-value items.

Conclusion:  When storing valuable equipment, security is key. For those who want the best way to lock a shed, metal sheds are the superior option. Their heavy-duty, lockable doors and sturdy frames offer enhanced protection against theft. Resin sheds, while lockable, are generally not as secure as metal options.

4. Maintenance

Maintenance can impact how much time and money you spend on keeping your shed in good condition.

Metal Sheds

• Annual inspections for rust, scratches, and chips are needed to keep metal sheds in top shape.
• Occasional touch-up paint and rust treatment will prolong the life of the shed.
• Ventilation slots should be cleared of debris regularly.

Plastic/Resin Sheds

• Minimal upkeep: No need for painting, staining, or sealing.
• Cleaning is as simple as a wash with soap and water. No rust, rot, or insect damage to worry about.

Conclusion: Resin sheds are the clear winner when it comes to low-maintenance storage, while metal sheds require regular care to maintain their appearance and functionality.

5. Assembly & Installation

Setting up your shed is another important consideration. While both types come as DIY kits, the assembly process can vary.

Metal Sheds

• More components and heavier panels make assembly time-consuming. It’s usually a two-person job.
• Metal panels need to be aligned carefully, and small mistakes can be frustrating to correct.

Plastic/Resin Sheds

• Easier and faster to assemble, with lighter panels that often snap or click into place.
• Fewer fasteners and simpler instructions make resin sheds ideal for first-time buyers or those with limited DIY experience.

Conclusion: Resin sheds are much easier and faster to assemble, while metal sheds require more time and effort.

6. How Does It Look in Your Backyard?

Your shed will be a visible part of your outdoor space, so aesthetics matter.

Metal Sheds

• Once known for their industrial look, modern metal sheds come in various earthy colours like brown, green, and grey.
• Many can be painted to match your home’s exterior, offering customization beyond just colour.

Plastic/Resin Sheds

• Resin sheds have made significant improvements in appearance, often featuring wood-effect finishes that mimic timber sheds.
• They come in clean, contemporary designs that fit seamlessly into modern outdoor spaces.

While we focus on metal vs wood sheds, metal and resin provide unique advantages, offering better durability, security, and weather resistance compared to wood.

7. What Does Your Budget Buy?

Both types of sheds come with their own price points, but the overall value varies depending on the material.

Metal Sheds

• More affordable: Prices for smaller sheds start around $330–$500, with larger units ranging from $600–$900.
• Metal sheds require minimal maintenance and can last decades.

Plastic/Resin Sheds

• Higher initial cost, typically starting around $390, with larger units priced between $750–$900.
• Lower total cost of ownership due to the lack of maintenance needs over time.

Conclusion: Metal sheds are a budget-friendly option upfront, but resin sheds offer long-term value with lower maintenance costs.

Best Use Cases: Who Should Buy Which?

Ultimately, the right shed depends on your specific needs.

Choose a Metal Shed if you:

• Need to store heavy or high-value items.
• Live in an area with high winds, heavy snowfall, or wildfire risk.
• I want a long-lasting shed with manageable upkeep.

Choose a Plastic/Resin Shed if you:

• Need a low-maintenance solution for garden tools, seasonal décor, or bikes.
• Live in a humid or coastal climate.
• I want a modern look with zero upkeep.

Top Metal Sheds

Here are some of the top metal sheds available at Aosom Canada.

Product Name	Key Features	Best For	Buy Now
Outsunny 11′ x 13′ Garden Storage Shed with Foundation Kit – White	Foundation kit, double doors, galvanized steel panels, lockable door	Significant outdoor gear storage	View Product
Outsunny 11′ x 13′ Garden Storage Shed with Double Sliding Doors – Green	Sliding doors, galvanized steel, 4 ventilation slots	Smaller backyard gardens	View Product
Outsunny 4.6′ x 9′ Steel Lean-to Shed with Foundation Kit – Dark Grey	Lean-to design, foundation kit, 2 air vents, lockable door	Side-yard storage	View Product
Outsunny 8.5′ x 6′ Galvanized Steel Outdoor Storage Shed – Dark Grey	Window panel, wide double doors, air vents	Workshop or hobby space	View Product
Outsunny 11′ x 9′ Steel Garden Storage Shed with Double Sliding Doors – Grey	Double sliding doors, 2 air vents	Large outdoor storage	View Product

Top Plastic/Resin Sheds

Here are some of the top plastic sheds available at Aosom Canada.

Product Name	Key Features	Best For	Buy Now
Outsunny 4′ x 3′ Plastic Garden Shed with Floor – Dark Grey	Compact design, water-repellent, UV4, lockable door, side window, top vent	Organizing tools in small spaces	View Product
Outsunny 8′ x 6′ Plastic Garden Storage Shed with Latch Door – Light Grey	Waterproof polypropylene, 10mm recycled plastic, aluminum reinforcement, dual vents, large door	Spacious and secure storage with airflow	View Product
Outsunny 4.5′ x 6′ Plastic Garden Storage Shed with Latch Door – Dark Grey	Waterproof polypropylene, sloped roof, large door, two air vents, side window	Compact shed with good ventilation	View Product

Finding the Perfect Shed for Your Needs

When it comes to choosing the right shed, the decision ultimately depends on your specific requirements.  No matter which you choose, Aosom offers a wide range of top-quality sheds to help transform your outdoor space. Explore our sheds today and make your storage needs a seamless part of your yard’s aesthetic.

FAQs